Thucydides, the peloponnesian war, the Melian Dialogue ( Book 5, Essay

Thucydides, the peloponnesian war, the Melian Dialogue ( give 5, chapter 17) - Essay ExampleThe Melians was a colony of many islands, but Athens wouldnt submit to them. They remained unbiassed and didnt s tussle with the people. Athenians used violence to evict the Melians from their territory and this made the Melians change their status and became hostile.In the Melian dialogue, Athenians demanded the Melians to give up on their city and compensate them for the destruction caused in the city. In response, the Melians claimed that they would remain neutral and not become enemies so instead they offered friendship. The Athenians argued that they would look weak and the people would undermine their violence, if they real the Melians to be neutral and independent (Crawley 2). The Melians countered that it would be a shame and an act of cowardice if they surrendered without a fight. Thucydides say that, if such an action is taken to keep your empire and your people will not be d ischarge and will subdued to slavery, then the people who are free will be considered cowards and weak if they break in to face everything. The Athenians responded and stated that the debate wasnt about honor, but of self-preservation.The Melians stated that the Athenians were strong and they could easily win. In response, the Athenians stated that the strong were hopeful and the weak Melians were hopeless and outnumbered. The Melians responded that they had great help from their gods, but Thucydides stated that pull in god would give prosperity for those who stood for the right and not wrong. The Athenians response to the Melians was that gods and man value strength over integrity and the strong can make it but the weak suffer (Crawley 3-4). The Melians argued that the Spartans would come and attend them in their defense. The Athenians responded to this by stating that the Spartans had little to their advantage and more to lose by aiding the Melians. The Athenians concluded that there was goose egg wrong in getting a strong enemy, but this statement didnt change